Change evidence report
PR 1892 replaces the presentation-style evidence archive and report shell with a restrained dashboard layout. A permanent desktop sidebar keeps navigation and report metadata visible, while narrow screens retain a compact sticky utility. The static renderer now reserves orientation-aware screenshot dimensions so lazy image loading does not move long reports.
e5e70ab2b (merge-base with main)…4f5fda639 (captured implementation head)Reviewer brief
The archive and report use the same viewport shell as the CRM dashboard: a stable sidebar, a separately scrolling content pane, compact bordered surfaces and clear page sections. Desktop reviewers keep report navigation and metadata in view. Mobile reviewers keep the product identity and section links in a sticky compact utility without horizontal page overflow.
Matched screenshots show the archive and the same sample report at base e5e70ab2b and implementation head 4f5fda639. Browser measurements establish layout persistence, responsive collapse, anchor clearance and stable document height. The report does not prove production deployment or replace pull request review and CI.
Claim map
Each material changed behavior or state maps to direct evidence or an explicit gap.
| Behavior or claim | Evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|
| The evidence archive uses a permanent utility sidebar and a denser dashboard hierarchy | Matched 1440 by 1000 archive screenshots | Covered |
| Individual reports keep section navigation and report metadata visible beside the content | Matched 1440 by 1000 report screenshots plus a sidebar position measurement before and after content scrolling | Covered |
| Narrow screens retain a compact sticky utility without obscuring anchored content or causing horizontal page overflow | Matched 390 by 844 report screenshots and live browser geometry measurements | Covered |
| Lazy screenshots reserve their rendered dimensions, including rotated JPEGs | Stable browser scroll-height measurement and an EXIF orientation regression test | Covered |
| The evidence JSON schema and publishing workflow remain compatible | Focused schema and renderer tests, package typecheck and production Vite build | Covered |
Observed change
Evidence is grouped by the reviewer question each item addresses.
Evidence archive
ScreenshotSame PR 1800 source report and 1440 by 1000 viewport. The base uses a large presentation hero. The proposed archive keeps workspace status in a full-height sidebar and makes the report queue the primary content.
Desktop report
ScreenshotSame PR 1800 report and 1440 by 1000 viewport. The content is unchanged. Its navigation and source metadata move from a wide hero and horizontal strip into the permanent sidebar.
Mobile report
ScreenshotSame PR 1800 report at 390 by 844. The desktop sidebar becomes a sticky product bar and horizontal section utility. Report metadata remains available on desktop, while mobile gives reading width to the evidence itself.
Browser measurements
TableMeasurements came from the built site served locally, not from source inspection.
| Scenario | Observed result |
|---|---|
| Desktop sidebar after content scroll | Top stayed 0px; width stayed 280px; content scrollTop reached 1200px |
| 1024px responsive report | Before and after evidence pairs collapsed to one 680.562px column |
| Lazy image layout | Content scrollHeight stayed 28,470px before and after entering evidence; all 32 images carried validated width and height attributes |
| 390px report | Document scrollWidth equalled the 390px viewport; anchored evidence began at 116px below the 98.875px sticky utility |
| Keyboard focus | Mobile section link used a visible 2px accent outline inset by 2px inside the horizontal scroller |
Confidence
16 pass, 0 fail, 42 assertions across scripts/pr-evidence/report.test.ts and packages/pr-evidence/src/site.test.ts
bun run --filter @sauna-crm/pr-evidence typecheck exited 0
Vite 6.4.3 built the archive and standalone report pages successfully
Live Chromium checks covered 1440 by 1000, 1024 by 900 and 390 by 844 viewports, persistent utilities, responsive collapse, focus visibility, anchor clearance, page width and image layout stability
A design reviewer and a code reviewer found responsive, focus, contrast and image-dimension defects. The final source-only follow-ups reported no remaining material findings
Limits
Section links do not track scroll position The report remains a self-contained, script-free artifact. The permanent section links navigate correctly but do not highlight the section currently in view. Avoiding client JavaScript keeps rendering deterministic and preserves the restrictive Content Security Policy.
Captures use the existing PR 1800 sample report The viewer refactor does not change report content. PR 1800 is the only checked-in source report at the merge-base, so each pair uses that same report and source images to isolate the shell change.