Change evidence report
PR 1979 turns the evidence archive into a compact review ledger and moves every standalone report onto the same restrained visual system. Report provenance now remains visible on desktop, mobile, and print. Before-and-after panels stay side by side until their content container requires stacking, while code and tables remain keyboard-scrollable without widening the page.
9d8fdc955 (merge-base with main)…78ce06621 (captured implementation head)Reviewer brief
The archive removes a single-purpose desktop sidebar and duplicated calls to action in favor of a dense, keyboard-aware report ledger. Standalone reports retain a useful section rail, move source metadata into the document itself, and share one stylesheet with the archive. The resulting pages keep strict CSP, deterministic static generation, dark and light schemes, narrow-screen navigation, and printable provenance.
Matched captures compare the same checked-in archive data and PR 1800 sample report at the 1440 by 1000 desktop viewport and the 390 by 844 mobile viewport. Live Chromium measurements cover navigation, overflow, responsive comparison layout, standalone styling, disclosure behavior, color schemes, and print output. The report does not prove the post-merge production promotion or replace CI and reviewer approval.
Claim map
Each material changed behavior or state maps to direct evidence or an explicit gap.
| Behavior or claim | Evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|
| The archive is organized as a compact, scan-first report ledger | Matched 1440 by 1000 archive screenshots with the same seven reports | Covered |
| Standalone reports keep useful section navigation while provenance remains part of the document | Matched 1440 by 1000 PR 1800 report screenshots plus five rendered report facts | Covered |
| Narrow reports retain identity, navigation, provenance, and reading width without page overflow | Matched 390 by 844 PR 1800 screenshots and live width measurements | Covered |
| Tables and code preserve keyboard-controlled horizontal scrolling without clipping their containers | Focusable overflow regions, preserved code width, and symmetric 25px table insets measured in Chromium | Covered |
| Standalone rendering, CSP, source escaping, and the publishing build remain compatible | Focused renderer tests, typecheck, report validation, and a production Vite build | Covered |
| The canonical evidence site is republished after merge | Production promotion occurs only after this pull request merges and the release workflow succeeds | Gap |
Observed change
Evidence is grouped by the reviewer question each item addresses.
Evidence archive
ScreenshotSame seven checked-in reports at 1440 by 1000. The base spends a permanent rail on one destination and repeats each internal report target. The candidate uses a compact product header, one internal title link, one external pull request link, and flat rows optimized for date and title scanning.
Desktop report
ScreenshotSame PR 1800 report at 1440 by 1000. The section rail remains, but repository, scope, revision range, source state, and publication time move into the report header so mobile and printed output retain them.
Mobile report
ScreenshotSame PR 1800 report at 390 by 844. Both versions retain sticky section navigation. The candidate adds a persistent PR identifier, keeps the full source facts in the document, and reserves horizontal scrolling for the controls and evidence that require it.
Live browser measurements
TableMeasurements came from the production Vite build served locally in Chromium.
| Scenario | Observed result |
|---|---|
| Archive at 1440 by 1000 | 7 report rows, 7 internal report links, 7 external PR links, one loaded stylesheet, and no horizontal page overflow |
| Standalone PR 1903 report | 5 report facts, 4 state-labelled panels, 2 focusable tables, 3 focusable code regions, no external stylesheet, no unresolved marker, and no horizontal page overflow |
| PR 1903 at 390 by 844 | Document width equalled the 390px viewport; the comparison stacked to one 356px column; code retained 614px scroll width inside a 356px region; the 411px TOC scrolled inside 374px |
| Mobile evidence table | Left and right insets both measured 25px and document width remained 390px after the independent review fix |
| Print emulation | Navigation was hidden, report facts remained a grid, the first evidence block stayed with its section heading, later blocks paginated, and Chromium rendered a 462,739-byte A4 PDF |
Confidence
33 pass, 0 fail, 167 assertions across renderer, notifier, workflow, and archive tests
bun run --filter @sauna-crm/pr-evidence typecheck exited 0
Vite 6.4.3 built the archive, shared stylesheet, and seven standalone report pages successfully
Live Chromium checks covered 1440 by 1000 and 390 by 844 layouts, dark and light schemes, navigation, disclosure state, overflow regions, container-query stacking, and A4 print output
The reviewer found one clipped table-margin calculation. The corrected auto width produced symmetric 25px insets and the focused follow-up found no remaining material issue.
Limits
Section links do not track scroll position Reports remain self-contained and script-free. Section links navigate correctly, but the current section is not highlighted while scrolling. Avoiding a client runtime preserves deterministic rendering and the restrictive Content Security Policy.
Production promotion follows merge This report proves the local production build and live browser behavior. The canonical evidence URL remains on the previously published UI until the pull request merges and the trusted release workflow promotes and byte-compares the new deployment.